The exchange seam in the RHF spectrum and canonical MP2¶
Paper 1’s exchange-seam equation and Paper 2’s MP2 denominator use the signed self-potential xi. The Gamma driver calls its negative the Madelung parameter. In SeamSpectrum.lean, t is a change in xi (hartree). Keep the overlap, one-electron terms, finite fit, topology and electron count fixed.
For a real supercell or a complex character block, write the spin-summed closed-shell density as D = 2 C C*, where C* S C = I and * is the adjoint. The Fock change is t S D S/2. Acting on C gives t S C; acting on any U with C* S U = 0 gives zero. Thus any old generalized eigenframe is still an eigenframe, with t added only to the occupied eigenvalues. This does not fix a particular basis within a degeneracy, or guarantee that a reordered spectrum has the same Aufbau partition. In the metric stationarity equation the two additional products are both t S D S D S/2, even without idempotency. At admissible real supercell densities, the existing trace and normalization results reduce the energy change to t Ne/2 per cell. This same constant at every density preserves all global minimizers on the common domain.
For each allowed ordered excitation define d = ei+ej-ea-eb and w = (|g|^2 + |g-g_ex|^2/2)/Nk^3, in primitive-factor conventions. The existing complex MP2 identity gives this nonnegative weight after summing over the exchange-closed virtual labels. The new ledger theorem identifies that sum with E(t) = sum w/(d+2t). Here both occupied levels shift; neither virtual level shifts. A common change of energy origin cancels. Subtract the two fractions term by term:
E(t)-E(0) = -2t sum w/[d(d+2t)].
Away from poles, margins g0 <= |d| and g1 <= |d+2t| give an absolute bound 2|t| sum(w)/(g0 g1). If d <= -g0 and 2|t| < g0, the new denominators remain negative with margin at least g0-2|t|. On a negative-denominator interval raising the occupied energies makes the raw correlation energy no greater. These are fixed-frame statements: a bare-to-periodic interaction change, a new fit, changed occupations or an orbital relaxation can change the numerators too.
The native checker runs a two-cell Gamma H2 calculation with and without the seam on the same fit. It compares generalized eigenpairs at one density and spectra of both converged SCFs. For asymmetric three-cell H2 it runs public chi MP2 at the required BvK-Ewald reference. Only for the sensitivity test does it pass shifted energies to the internal doubles kernel. A four-label reciprocal-lattice loop with rephased orbitals constructs the opposite-transfer integrals independently. The controls shift both orbital sectors together, omit one occupied shift, or cross the denominator threshold. See seam-spectra-results.json in either paper archive for the two results and the exact source and binary identities. Run formal/check_aiccm_seam_spectra.py in the identified runtime through vq and python3 formal/check_proofs.py with the pinned Lean environment.